Which is more effective? The Kettlebell Snatch or the Kettlebell Clean and Press?

I’ve been getting more questions lately about rotating between the Snatch and the Clean + Press in training cycles.

One of the common concerns is losing pressing strength by switching to “Snatch Only” programming.

It sets up the question either knowingly or unknowingly -

“Which is more effective - the Snatch or the Clean + Press?”

Better for the actual purpose .

So, before you feel any sort of urgency to make a decision between the two, here’s why I like incorporating the two:

SNATCH.

(By default, I’m talking about the single KB version)

[+] Perfect for training power production - found in almost every sport worth participating in

[+] Superb for improving “conditioning” and cardiovascular fitness - so it enhances performance and health

[+] Strong for ripping off body fat

[+] Great for training the “Outer Unit” of your core

[+] Valuable for making your posterior chain - glutes, hamstrings, and calves - more powerful

[+] Great for strengthening your grip

[+] Helpful for making your upper back (traps) stronger

And the Snatch has even been known for -

[+] Building bigger biceps

[+] Making your Press stronger

Speaking of…

THE CLEAN + PRESS

The Single Clean + Press

Does nearly everything that the Snatch does, and more , including:

[+] Fortifies the triceps and shoulders directly

[+] Grows muscle tissue on the triceps and shoulders directly

Plus, for some, it “patterns” the Snatch, which is beneficial all on its own.

The Double Clean + Press

… Is my top Clean + check here Press.

And that’s because of the “systemic overload” -

Which means it’s harder on your body than the single version because you’re using greater resistance (in most cases).

And that means you -

[+] Get stronger faster

[+] Grow more muscle faster

And for some, depending on the rep ranges used, you…

[+] Burn fat faster

So I don’t really look at one as more effective than the other. They’re separate tools in the same box.

How do you design them?

Again, that’s a question I’ve been receiving frequently.

A lot of people report great results cycling cycles of the two.

For example, 4 weeks of ‘THE GIANT’ followed by 3 weeks of KSK.

Works perfectly.

Here’s what “@JamesPTA” said (Check video)

But you don’t have to cycle alternately if you don’t want to, which is kinda an “either / or” approach.

You can blend the two in the same training cycle and benefit from using both - which I tend to prefer more more, because I’m an “and / both” type of guy.

That’s what you’ll find in Kettlebell MAXIMORUM.

You’ll do the Snatch and the Double Clean + Press twice a week, using a “light-heavy” approach.

It’s 2x 6-week phases, for 12 weeks total.

In Phase 1, you’ll train for Power and Maximum Strength.

In Phase 2, you’ll train for Power Endurance and Strength-Endurance.

I think Brandon said it well (Check video)

And if you want to concentrate on your Clean + Press or Snatch only?

I’ll also leave links to ‘THE GIANT’ Clean + Press Strength & Conditioning program and “The King-Sized Killer” Snatch program below too.

Stay Strong,

Geoff

P.S. If you want to “level up” your “GAINZ”...

I highly suggest you learn how to Clean + Press and Snatch if you haven’t already.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *